Nothing Can Stop 'The Walking Dead'
From Dominating BookScan Top 20
Published: 12/10/2012 12:07am
As expected, Chris Ware's Building Stories from Pantheon takes #3. Selected by Publishers Weekly, the New York Times, and many others as one of the best books of the year, this book was strong in October and looks to stick in the top five for the remainder of the year.
DC's Superman: Earth One Volume 2 HC snags position #4. It's a strong debut for the second volume in this re-imagination of Superman, but I'm skeptical that it will stay strong next month, and I'm predicting a steep drop-off for this title. We'll see how things play out.
Marvel finally places in the top 20 with Avengers Vs. X-Men. This massive 568-page hardcover collects the main storyline of the recent company-wide crossover. Its retail price is $75, and oddly enough, that's likely to be what's driving sales of the book. My guess would be that most copies are being sold through Amazon, where as of this writing the book is discounted to $44.50. It contains 23 comics, so it's a good deal. Marvel advertised this as being a limited edition, suggesting that they were not going to go back for a second print run. (Not surprising considering the printing costs involved!) But if sales maintain at this level, it’s a safe bet that this edition won’t be so limited after all.
The first manga shows up at #7, and it’s no shock that it’s the latest volume of Naruto from VIZ Media. Following that same theme is the appearance of Kodansha's newest Sailor Moon in position #9, and then VIZ's Rosario + Vampire at #10. VIZ also has Vampire Knight at #14 and Blue Exorcist at #18, and then the last volume of manga to appear on the list is Seven Seas' Alice in the Country of Clover in the 20th position. That makes six volumes of manga total, with only two in the top 10, a relatively weak showing for the category. But that’s to be expected in a month of holiday shopping; books like The Walking Dead and Building Stories are good gifts, while the latest volume of a manga series is usually something you buy for yourself, so it gets no boost from the holiday buying season.
Dark Horse continues to succeed with its latest Avatar: The Last Airbender book by Gene Yang, while DK Publishing has two books in the game this month on the strength of that holiday gift-giving I just mentioned. First is their Avengers guide, a regular on the top 20 list in 2012. This month it’s joined by DC Comics: The Ultimate Character Guide. Curiously, the latter book released in summer of 2011, so it’s a bit of a mystery why it’s jumped up the list this month.
For those keeping track at home, the clear winner this month was Image Comics with eight The Walking Dead releases, followed by VIZ with four of their most popular manga series. DK has two books on the list, while Dark Horse, DC, Kodansha, Marvel, Pantheon and Seven Seas all have one each.
Next month look for The Walking Dead to continue to dominate the list, including the release of the fourth large omnibus, while the December 18 release of DC Comics: The New 52 Zero Omnibus should place well for at least a month. In addition, there’s a new Maximum Ride manga from Yen Press that should be in the list.
For past BookScan Top 20 Graphic Novel lists, see the "BookScan Top 20 GNs Index."
[Disclosure: Dallas Middaugh is the director of publishing services for Random House Publisher Services. RHPS provides distribution and other services for several graphic novel clients, including DC Comics, Kodansha Comics, Archie Comics, and Vertical. He has also worked with or for Viz Media, Oni Press, and Slave Labor Graphics, and he co-founded Seven Seas.]